Because I'd still have eight
After practically shearing off a pinky toe for the umpteenth time by clipping it on a table leg, I'm more and more curious about whether or not there are any real problems with having them removed. I wish I kidding, but sometimes my brain just goes into these places.
As far as I can tell, losing it wouldn't do any real harm. I'm one of those people with really wide feet, but not equally long (know what I mean, nudge nudge) so it would open up my shoe options. And then the really is the shearing off factor -- if I don't do it, chances are chance will do it for me. A few examples:
- Men are supposed to be better at this whole spatial navigation thing, at least that was the line, but I apparently really suck at it. I'll be turning the corner through a door, and no part of me hits anything except for the damn outside edge of my foot. There are a few chairs, and one bed, where this is particularly bad. I've come to the conclusion that I don't do corners well at all.
- I used to do Aikido fairly heavily... and not the 'fruity' variants which are basically just wide-circle tai-chi. There is no easier way to break a pinky toe (or any toe) than with a snap-kick. Different kicks require your toes to be in different positions, and it's easy to get them confused, and easy to just go in at the wrong angle. It will ruin your damn day.
- It's not like I was raised in the depression, but I figure I burn enough electricity through my other appliances that if I don't need a light on, and I know where I'm going and know the layout of where I am, there's no point to it. Plus, it helps me keep my CTR-vision. This generally works fine, unless someone has left a chair out ever so much, and then I'm caught swearing. And no, I don't know how I got it into my head that echo-location was a reasonable way for a human to get around.
Now, even if there is some sort of value derived from the pinky toe in terms of balance, etc. I'd have to assume losing it isn't akin to losing your inner ear or large toes, and it's not as though I'm running through the trees much. I'm looking at it, and from an evolutionary standpoint, it doesn't seem to be doing so well compared to the others.
I don't think I'm alone in my whimsical question of whether removing them should be akin to having your appendix removed, as the Pinky Toe Haiku so eloquently sums up:
Hark, wee pinky toe
Unnoticed, tiny, deformed
What is your purpose?
I also don't understand why -- for something so seemingly insignificant -- nature has set it up to be so incredibly painful if you harm it. Breaking your pinky toe is much more painful than your finger, and even just jamming it is much more painful than jamming a finger. Basically, nothing about the damn thing adds up and my own body seems confused about it.
I've been googling a lot of medical things lately (Hepatitis-C for one, because a reader turned me onto it and it's something I'm fairly ignorant about, and polio and iron lungs being the others) and this is an area I've come up fairly short on. The great thing about google is that -- at least for something like Hepatitis-C -- while it may not have all the info you're after, it can connect you to the support groups which are treasure troves of real-world issues.
There apparently isn't anything like that for those encumbered by their pinky toes, although I did find a page on losing your toes to diabetes that made me go with a granola bar for lunch, and I learned there are new cosmetic procedures to shape your ass via sandblasting. I thought I'd hit the jackpot when I found a page of what looked to be about those who had had toes amputated, but that was short lived.
I don't don't know what the hell that page is about, but it takes one hard left turn into aberrant behavior that had me in back-away-slowly-and-don't-make-eye-contact-mode, and there aren't many sites that have really accomplished that.
I'm laying off the medical googling for awhile, but it'd still be nice to have a real answer on it some day. I did bring it up with a doctor once on a lark, but that didn't get very far. I probably didn't help my cause by also mentioning having some protective metal plate installed -- hey, it works for heads.
Human-Computer-Interface (HIC) design says the computer should adapt to how I do things, not the other way around, so why shouldn't my body work the same way?
Comments (31)
Posted by: Electric Monk at March 30, 2005 06:45 PM
Honestly it seems pretty reasonable to me.
I'd say go for it if it isn't too expensive.
Hmmm. My pinky's do bother me in my sneakers sometimes…
And you're absolutely right that hurting the pinky is ludicrously painful.
I think you're on to something.
Posted by: rob at March 30, 2005 06:52 PM
My little toes are weird - they're about a centimetre long, and don't even touch the ground when I put my foot flat.
I'm a hideous freak :(
Posted by: icedtrip at March 30, 2005 06:56 PM
Personally I liked the protective metal plate idea. Why not replace the pinky tow nail with something like a small, well shaped, rounded, and filed down piece of titanium. That should offer you some protection while giving you a little bling if not the ability to match a powerbook.
Posted by: Mathew Burgraph at March 30, 2005 07:39 PM
this link is just terrible.
http://durrrrr.blogspot.com/
i can see some would think it is funny, but it goes too far
Posted by: Diggory Laycock at March 30, 2005 07:43 PM
I seem to remember that the loss of the little toe has a surprisingly large detrimental effect on balance.
Posted by: Ankalon at March 30, 2005 08:08 PM
Diggory:
I thought that was the big toe that caused you to lose balance? Being that the big toe is sort of "load bearing" when you move. (Besides, they seem to be vestigial anyway. Like your appendix.)
Posted by: Twist at March 30, 2005 08:26 PM
Maybe they should just chop them off right after we are born like a certain part of the male anatomy which is removed for no good reason at all.
Posted by: d at March 30, 2005 08:41 PM
The pinky toe is vestigial. It's just a matter of a few million years to make it "evolve away".
The only really essential toe is the big one: it helps you balance.
Posted by: feaverish at March 30, 2005 08:59 PM
A couple of years ago, while running through the apartment to answer the phone, I kicked — with the full force of my run — a corner of wall with the pinky toe of my left foot. Imagine kicking a corner as hard as you can, with bare feet, and only connecting with your pinky. Anyway, it wasn't broken, but it swelled-up and turned purple and stayed that way for weeks. Also, it hurt.
Posted by: shane at March 30, 2005 09:15 PM
A foot fetishist here weighing in that the pinky toe is not essential to the erotic enjoyment of a foot either, though the point is surely up for debate.
Posted by: Troy at March 30, 2005 09:20 PM
Today's entry sure has confused the Google Ads :)
Posted by: "Crocodile" Leechman at March 30, 2005 10:09 PM
Crikey, mate, you're onto a bottler of an idea there. Ya know, if I bred leeches to go after toes, I'll bet I'd have a bonzer market!
Posted by: Nate at March 30, 2005 10:14 PM
Yes, the pinky toe does have a tremendous effect on balance. My fiancee had a toe bone split when she was a kid, and after her operation she had a helluva time getting around (she was used to her freak toe =)
Then again, I'm sure there are people who have lost their pinky toes and can still walk, it'd just take a bit of getting used to, that's all.
Posted by: Squozen at March 31, 2005 12:38 AM
Thanks guys, I've read this entire page with my hand over my mouth in horror...
Posted by: Adrian at March 31, 2005 03:59 AM
I would be aware of two facts before parting with my pinky toe.
1. The wound left after amputation will take a couple of weeks to heal. If you really are that clumsy with your feet as you mentioned the healing process might take a long time if you keep hitting things. If things heal up nicely I don't think that hitting the joint where the toe was severed is any less painful.
2. The phantom itch. I heard people say that alone the phantom itch is a reason to beg the doctor not to amputate a leg. I don't know how bad a severed toe can itch but if it does it might be just as annoying as hitting it every once in a while.
Thanks for the entertainment.
Posted by: Rich W at March 31, 2005 06:21 AM
It'll fsck0r up your balance. Your brain deduces an awful lot from the position of the little toe.
Posted by: aaron at March 31, 2005 08:22 AM
My sister an I are further advanced (in regards to vestigial toes) than some of the other posters here. Neither one of us has any nail on our piny toes. I seem to recall that she put's nail polish on the skin so as not to be too freaky. But I could be mistaken. Especially if she reads this.
Posted by: Jon H at March 31, 2005 08:29 PM
I could really go for life without toenails. They're really more trouble than they're worth, especially when they get ingrown.
Posted by: Matt at April 1, 2005 01:46 AM
I whack into door frames all the time. It's like my brain thinks I'm a full 6cm smaller (horizontally) than I really am.
Posted by: SusanDK at April 1, 2005 06:17 PM
hey, this toe navigation error thing makes me think of the hate furniture that had a corner my dad used to hit his toe on when I was a little girl, and how impressed I was when he took a saw, and cut it off - not the pinky toe, but that damned corner! Today, I'm the owner of this chatterbox, it is actually an antiquity but a very fargile and badly treated one! And my husband sent to to get restaurated by a friend of his, an amateur handyman who told us he was very good at freshing up old furniture. Whe he brough it back, after six months, he had decided to also cut off the right side corner, to make symmetry! Now, we don't have to even think of toe amputations any longer :-)
Posted by: Peter da Silva at April 2, 2005 12:29 PM
My problem is door handles. I've pretty much convinced my brane to avoid furniture, but doors *move*, so they're not where I remember them... and *whack*. Not the door, just the handle.
I'm also moderately tall (6'), and I used to have a couple of pairs of pants with the pockets at exactly the right height to snag the door handle if I managed to miss it with my hipbone or thigh. You'll notice that I said "had"...
Posted by: Adrian at April 8, 2005 09:39 AM
Here to report my joining the league of toe hitters. Just mistook a door for a football and broke the fourth toe of my left foot. The pinky toe is unharmed and with the help of some tape serves as a splint for the fourth toe. It's only now that I truly appreciate the importance of my pinky toe. :-)
I can only give this advice: Don't storm to the phone if you don't have any shoes on.
Posted by: Scott at April 19, 2005 11:32 AM
I don't think they're used much for balance. I was born with my right pinky toe overlapping onto the next toe so it's never touched the ground. Never had any problems walking. Oddly enough I've occasionally banged my left one on a chair or something but since the right one is up out of the way, it stays unscathed.
Posted by: felicity+cassie at November 15, 2005 01:13 PM
we have very much enjoyed the site! we are researcing aputation of our little toes for medical research and whether it serves a purpose at all. you get 5 grand to have it off and sewed back on. there is only a 30% chance it will go black and fall off, which we think is pretty low! one of our toes is overlapping the 4th and seems to serve no purpose and the other one has a normal toe. we need the money and you must admit comedy value - 10!
Posted by: Joe at February 2, 2006 04:20 PM
My doctor said if you remove a toe the problem will just go on to the next one.
Posted by: TT` at March 7, 2006 05:21 PM
So What is the answer? Big toe balance or little toe balance?
Posted by: cory at March 10, 2006 10:14 PM
I have no toes. It sucks i cant walk. i cant afford a wheel chair so i crawl around my house. I cant reach cabinets so i have to hope my crazy cat with one eye knocks stuff over for me to eat of the floor. I live very much like a dog. I sure miss my toes. Its a shame i ate them.
Posted by: Cory at March 10, 2006 10:16 PM
P.S. dont cut fof your pinky toe. I tried glueing mine back on. Doesnt work. Than i ate it. Boy do I regret that.
Posted by: Phil at April 27, 2006 08:44 AM
i have all my toes and im perfectly normal, i feel sorry for you freaks, although your stories of pain and trivialisation amuses me hahahahaha, i hate you all
Love Phil








Admit it, you're just being random on purpose. :^)