A Real gamble
Had this come across the desk this morning... RealNetworks is really trying to heat things up, and are coming out of their corner firing:
...the temporary discount, making songs 49 cents and most albums $4.99, came at the same time as the full public launch of the newest version of the company's RealPlayer jukebox software."
That's drastic enough to get a hell of a lot of press, and continue their (for the moment) successful mindshare campaign to actually be seen as relevant.
I have to give RealNetworks a tip of the hat here. They don't have a massive installed base who could quickly bleed the company dry with millions of half-priced downloads and, at the moment, it's not about actually selling the songs, but cementing their technology for licensing. The more users they have in their service, the more willing the makers of digital players will be to license their technology.
Not only that, it continues to perpetuate the idea of Apple being anti-competitive in the market and insulating their users from that pesky competition competition thing. Whether you agree or not, they're doing a pretty good job of pushing the idea of lock-in; you can buy an iPod, but you can't listen to RealNetworks $0.49 192kbps AAC songs even if you weren't aware of how limited your options would be. Real would love to sell them to you, but they aren't being allowed to... Apple wants to take its ball and go home.
Pretty brilliant, really. But a gamble:
...company also said it would launch its biggest ad campaign for digital music, with print, radio and online spots centered on the idea of "Freedom of Choice."
This campaign is going to generate a lot of noise, but it's going to be very, very expensive noise.
It's worth noting that RealNetworks' market cap has evaporated by a good ~30-35% since June. Back in July, analysts were expecting a loss this quarter of $0.02/share, when Real widened their guidance to $0.03-$0.04/share and the stock took a beating. The market hasn't been doing well since, but RealNetworks has gotten a bounce recently through it's recent mindshare blitzkrieg.
With the announcement, RealNetworks guided that they could well lose up to $0.05/share. To a company of RealNetworks' size, this isn't chump change, and the market could go either way on this one... very bad things can start to happen to a company when its market cap gets too low.
But it's good to be aware of a few things:
- They currently have a current market cap of ~$880-890 million.
- They have revenues in the sub-$100 million range
- They are embroiled in a very, very costly anti-trust lawsuit with Microsoft at the moment, for damages exceeding a billion dollars
- A good chunk of their losses are due to the ongoing litigation
- They have technology in areas of DRM, server-side streaming and encoding
And it's also good to be aware that when one is trying to create selling momentum, or grooming a company for sale, there are some things one generally tries to do:
- Gain as great a brand awareness as possible; in many cases a company brand is worth more than their assets or revenues
- Increase revenue/sales figures through aggressive campaigning or special deals
- Make your company riper for acquisition by focusing on the parts the most-likely potential 'synergistic' or 'strategic' buyers will be interested in; often profitable divisions can be sold off or dropped because they don't fit the profile.
- Create barriers to entry wherever one can. You want to make it easier for a potential suitor to buy you rather than just enter the market themselves in some cases, and in others they simply sweeten the proverbial pot.
There are other things you do, but I'm making a concerted effort to be sparse this time and the tinfoil hat is feeling a bit tight. But before I leave you, it's worth noting that Roxio recently dumped its profitable divisions to focus solely on the Napster brand.
All so very interesting.
Comments (8)
Posted by: Murph at August 17, 2004 10:04 AM
Microsoft buying Real would be THE SUCK. Walmart would then buy Napster. DOUBLE SUCK. But then Walmart might buy Microsoft. COOL.
Posted by: Chris P at August 17, 2004 10:26 AM
What an evil idea. Would M$ buy someone who is suing them in court though? I wonder could Apple buy Real?
Posted by: Tamas Jakab at August 17, 2004 10:38 AM
Why would Apple buy Real? What technology does Real have that Apple already doesn't?
Posted by: Dave at August 17, 2004 11:36 AM
Wouldn't Real's market cap:profit ratio make a purchase unlikely in these post .com days?
Posted by: Cale at August 17, 2004 06:37 PM
I think the key words here are "temporary discount." The Motley Fool has an interesting article in which they portray this move as just a last-ditch effort by Real to make inroads into iTunes' market share. Real may have initial success with the lower prices, but people will go right back to iTunes once prices are equal again. The iTunes experience is just too good.
http://www.fool.com/News/mft/2004/mft04081716.htm
Posted by: T at August 17, 2004 10:12 PM
Dave I do not know RealNetworks market specifics like their float size or cash on hand but I think what he is saying is that if Microsoft has the option of paying Real a billion plus in a settlement (googling shows Real has also filed for an injuction) and just buying Real it could be attractive. I do not know specifics but cannot see the shareholders agreeing to less than $7 per share or somewhere near 1.5 billion. I read Microsoft just paid Sun two billion+ for a similar lawsuit.
Googling on synergist and strategic buyers says Microsoft would be getting technology and subscriber customers that are important to them for their own music store. I think that is coming in Longhorn. It could make sense Microsoft has been trying to end all their lawsuits.
Posted by: Anon at August 18, 2004 06:14 AM
Good call this could be really bad for Apple. The people may try to go back to itunes but they wont want to throw away their music. The more people RealNetworks gets using ther Harmony software the better the chance that Apple will be forced not to "cut off" access to the iPod with software upgrades or risk enraging tens of thousands of people.








http://www.freedomofmusicchoice.org/ - yay for propaganda.
One point I read about this somewhere was that Real don't support MacOS X for their download service - freedom of music choice, with the caveat of which operating system you choose.